Calgary Photographic Society
November 2004 Newsletter
Ever since I joined the Calgary Photographic Society, I have always enjoyed the annual Scavenger Hunt and the Christmas brunch, the as well as the photographic outings. Why?
These events offer a great opportunity to socialize with CPS members, meet their significant others, and in some cases, meet other members of their families or their friends. These are great times for sharing experiences and camaraderie with a group of individuals who have more than one thing (photography) in common.
I encourage you to attend the two upcoming events, I guarantee you will enjoy them!
Our scavenger hunt is taking place at the Devonian Gardens downtown on Sunday, November 7. That same day we will have a BBQ at Stephen's place to relax and share our stories of the day.
Our annual Christmas gathering is taking place on Sunday, December 5 at the Glencoe Club. Official announcements of these two events will be made at the November 3 club meeting as well as via email.
Last but not least, I want to thank Stephen Butt for hosting the BBQ, and Brian Henson for making all the arrangements with the Glencoe Club.
Sincerely, José.
José Guillén,
President of the Calgary Photographic Society.
Club Meeting, October 6 2004
The guest speaker at our October meeting was our own CPS club member Brian Henson. Brian's chosen topic was "Ramblings of an Old Fart," as he had a number of topics he wanted to cover.
He brought along a number of his exceptional prints to demonstrate the points he was making. His images are created from regular and infrared monochrome negatives, shot on medium format and occasionally 35mm cameras.
Brian Henson
Brian joined the Calgary Photographic Society in 1991. In the past, he has paid his dues as a member of the executive.
Brian is a very active photographer. He's known to hop in his car for photographic junkets to other provinces and to the USA. As well, he has flown to other countries in his quest for images. At several CPS meetings in the past, Brian has made public invitations to others who might want to share in his adventures!
Brian's ability to spot and shoot an image that other photographers fail to see is well-known. But there are two sides to the print equation: in addition to being able to "see" an image and capture it on film, Brian is capable of ensuring that same image is created in his darkroom. Brian's darkroom prowess produces world-class prints!
Brian entered prints in the monthly competitions until 1999. When it got to the point that he consistently won in the advanced categories, he chose to withdraw from the competitions. Attendees of the monthly meetings now see his work in the "exhibition" category. Brian's images can be seen routinely at local galleries.
Brian's work is heavily influenced by that of Wynn Bullock, Edward Weston, and Ansel Adams. It's obvious he shares their views considering the number of times he quoted them during his presentation!
During his presentation, Brian took some time to dismantle a few photographic "rules."
In particular, he showed how robot-like adherence to one of his pet peeves - the so-called "Rule of Thirds" - could damage the composition of a print. He summarized, "I'd much rather work on my instincts than I would on rules."
Brian presented some comments made by judges from past competitions, and explained why the comments were inappropriate. This was both educational and entertaining.
Brian's thoughts on digital imaging versus classic techniques were no surprise to attendees.
Brian admitted that digitally-created colour prints are approaching the quality of opto-chemically created ones. However, he doesn't care for the colour manipulation that some people use.
Regarding digitally-created monochrome prints, however, he feels that digital printing techniques still have a long way to go. Presently-available printers, even ones costing $2500, don't produce prints up to Brian's standards. He stated that they all seem to produce "flat" prints.
He commented, "Emotion seems to be missing nowadays, particularly since digital has become prominent." And also, "You've got to get into the darkroom, don't ruin yourself on the computer!"
Brian summarized with a few tips for those who aspire to better printing.
Practice - a lot! A fellow CPS member spotted Brian purchasing a case of paper from a photo store, and wondered if Brian was going into mass production. Brian stated that he could go through that much paper in 6 months - and most of it winds up in the trash. He stated "you must print as though someone else is buying your paper for you!"
Make mistakes and learn from them in the darkroom. For example, Brian found by accident that printing a bit dark can sometimes bring out emotion in a print - and he had an example of this on display.
Enter competitions. Let others see and comment on your work. You'll learn from their comments - and it will thicken your skin!
Thanks for sharing your thoughts - and images - with us, Brian!
Club Meeting, October 6 2004
Print Competition Results
Theme: "Sunset"
Definition of Sunset:
"The apparent descent of the sun below the horizon, also:
the accompanying atmospheric effects"
Source: Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary
Judges for the print competition this month were Palle Kjar, Neil Koven and Scott Winter. The alternate judge was Stephen Butt.
Advanced Open
Norm Capper
"The Old Paint Shop"
| Score | Advanced Open | Title |
| 9.0 | Norm Capper | The Old Paint Shop |
| 8.6 | Scott Winter | Boats on the Ghost |
| 7.3 | Neil Koven | The Basket Maker |
| 7.0 | José Guillén | Spring in the Rockies |
Intermediate Open
Michael Sundberg
"Mission Beach"
| Score | Intermediate Open | Title |
| 7.3 | Michael Sundberg | Mission Beach |
| 5.6 | Marcelo Pinheiro | Forks |
Novice Open
No entrants this month
| Score | Novice Open | Title |
| - - - - - | No entrants this month | - - - - - |
Novice Theme
Maidie Couvillon
"B.C. Sunset"
| Score | Novice Theme | Title |
| 7.6 | Maidie Couvillon | B.C. Sunset |
Intermediate Theme
Marcelo Pinheiro
"Cold Sunset"
| Score | Intermediate Theme | Title |
| 7.6 | Marcelo Pinheiro | Cold Sunset |
| 7.0 | Michael Sundberg | Sunset at Clover Point |
| 5.6 | Doug Neal | After the Races |
Advanced Theme
Norm Capper
"View from Sentry Lodge"
| Score | Advanced Theme | Title |
| 8.6 | Norm Capper | View from Sentry Lodge |
| 7.3 | Neil Koven | Sunset at Malibu Beach |
Exhibition
Brian Henson
Untitled
| Score | Exhibition | Title |
| N/S | Brian Henson | Untitled (branches on dunes) |
| N/S | Brian Henson | Untitled (nude on log) |
Upcoming Competition Themes:
| Date | Theme | Definition |
| Nov 3 2004 |
Sharp |
"adapted to cutting or piercing", or "having a thin keen edge or fine point"
Source: Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary |
| Dec 1 2004 |
Gold(en) |
"a variable colour averaging deep yellow", or
"having the colour of metallic gold"
Source: Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary |
| Jan 5 2005 |
Glass |
"hard, usually brittle and transparent substance made by fusing sand"
Source: Oxford English Dictionary |
| Feb 2 2005 |
Underwear |
"clothing or an article of clothing worn next to the skin and under
other clothing"
Source: Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary |
| Mar 2 2005 |
Fence |
"a barrier intended to prevent escape or intrusion or to mark a
boundary, especially such a barrier made of posts and wire or boards."
Source: Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary |
| Apr 6 2005 |
Wheel |
"a circular frame of hard material that may be solid, partly solid, or
spoked and that is capable of turning on an axle"
Source: Webster's New Collegiate Dictionary |
Scavenger Hunt
The CPS scavenger hunt will take place on Sunday, November 7.
Photographers are to meet at 11:00AM at the Second Cup on the main floor of the Calgary Eaton Centre. This is located between 7th and 8th Ave SW, between 3rd and 4th St SW. On Sundays, the Sears parkade charges just $2 for the day; access is from 8th Ave, between 4th and 5th St SW.
At the gathering, participants will be provided with 3 items:
Part of the challenge to this event is that participants can't use their normal equipment; rather, all must use the same type of consumable camera. Photographers can also bring along their usual camera gear so no photo opportunities are lost, but judging will only be performed on the shots taken with the consumable cameras. Typically, there will be as many topics to shoot as there are frames in the camera!
Participants can shoot alone or in groups as desired.
Cameras must be turned in at 4:00PM when participants will gather for a barbeque and socializing at Stephen Butt's place. For the barbeque, participants are expected to bring their own steaks (or whatever is preferred) for the grill. The club will provide the trimmings - munchies, salad, soft drinks, etc.
Processing and judging will be performed at a later date. The results will be announced at the Dec 1 club meeting. At that time, winning prints will be displayed, and negatives and prints will be returned to the photographers. Modest prizes will be awarded to the photographers with the best images.
This event - being more social than serious - is open to all members, potential members, spouses, family, and friends. Anyone can buy a camera if they want to join the hunt, or simply come to the barbeque.
The cost for the event is $15 for members, $20 for non-members, or $5 for non-members attending the barbeque. This cost includes the camera and subsequent film processing plus a contribution for the barbeque.
If you're interested in participating, please contact an executive member so we can accommodate you!
Judging: - One Person's Opinion...
By Stephen Butt
Every month at CPS we have an opportunity to bring in a couple of our cherished works of art, only to have them torn apart by those "sanctimonious" judges. Over the years I have heard many comments about the judging methods and scoring, most of them negative. So I will review how the prints are scored and give you my deliberations on judging.
All prints in the open category are scored with whole numbers to a maximum of 10 points: 4 points for impact, 3 points for composition, and 3 points for technical.
In the theme category the point breakdown is 6 points for impact and adherence to the theme, 2 points for composition, and 2 points for technical.
When I review a print, I start by giving it a perfect 10. Then, I deduct points for what - in my opinion - are faults or areas that could be improved.
So just what are those "areas" that could be improved?
First I consider what class the image has been entered in. If it is in the advanced class I am going to be more critical than if it is in the novice class. If, for example, a print is made from a dusty negative, I will always comment on the dust spots in hopes that the photographer will learn something useful, but I will not necessarily deduct any points from the technical score on a novice image. I will certainly deduct points from an advanced image for the same "infraction."
In my mind this example is fairly straight forward, but here is where it gets a little trickier.
As far as composition and impact go, these areas are completely subjective. What I might think is a good composition, others may disagree on. The same goes for impact. It can be very subjective, and my opinion is simply that - my opinion - right or wrong.
Another thing to remember with prints in the theme category is that if the print is judged to not portray the theme, you will lose 3 points right from the start! A person could have a nice image, but if you lose 3 points for theme, you only need to lose a couple more points for other reasons, and pretty soon a really good image scores only a 5.
With all that I have said, the most important points to remember are:
So keep a stiff upper lip, bring in your images, and you never know - your photography just might get better!
Regards, Stephen
Enlarger Available!
CPS member Rinus Borgsteede has donated an enlarger and accessories to the club, to be used by club members! Rinus has suggested that it be loaned to any member who would like to try creating enlargements at home.
Scott Winter photo
All you need to add are chemistry, paper, and some darkness! This is a great way to try making your own prints. $75 will set you up with paper and chemistry for as many as 25 8x10" prints. And, since you'll be creating them yourself, they can be custom cropped, exposed, burned, and dodged - and they'll even be archival quality - at no extra cost!
If you are interested in trying out this unit, please contact Scott Winter at:
scott at winterphotographics.com
To Rinus we extend a big "Thank you" for this generous donation!
Current Events - Edward Weston Exhibition
Brian Henson alerts members to an Edward Weston exhibition
in Oregon:
Edward Weston: A Photographer’s Love of Life.
It will be held at the Portland Art Museum from Sept 11 to Nov 28 2004.
Meeting Notice
Our next club meeting will be held Wednesday November 3 2004. It will be held at 7:30PM at the University of Calgary, in the Kinesiology building. Our normal room is KN133; if there are availability problems, the alternate room used is typically KN129.
The guest speaker at our November meeting will be our own Neil Koven.
The subject of Neil's presentation will be "Seeing Through Neil's Eyes." Those who attend the meetings regularly are aware of Neil's photographic capabilities, both during and after the fieldwork.
Neil's presentation ought to be a good one - don't miss it!
Calgary Photographic Society
Contact Information
The 2004 executive is as follows:
| position | name |
| President | José Guillén |
| Treasurer | Norm Capper |
| Monthly Program Dir. | Harry Mah |
| External Program Dir. | Stephen Butt |
| Secretary | Julie Meisser |
| Archivist | Fran Williams |
| Newsletter Editor | Jack Dyck |
Contact information for the current executive can be found here.
This concludes the November 2004 newsletter.
If anyone has ideas for guest speakers for future meetings, please contact Harry Mah.
If members have material for the newsletter - announcements, news, exhibitions, awards, soapbox articles, wanted/for sale, etc - please forward to Jack Dyck.
See you at the November meeting! Don't forget to bring your prints for the competition theme "Sharp!"
Jack Dyck,
Newsletter Editor for the Calgary Photographic Society .